Easy Homemade Raw Milk Cottage Cheese: Probiotic & Delicious

Jump to Recipe Print Recipe

If you’ve ever wanted to try cheesemaking at home, this raw milk cottage cheese recipe is the perfect place to start. With just a few simple ingredients and no heating required, you can turn fresh raw milk into a soft, creamy, protein-rich cheese in just a day or two. It’s a simple, traditional way to use raw milk that fits beautifully into a real food kitchen—nourishing, versatile, and family-friendly.

In this post, I’ll show you how to make this raw milk cottage cheese in simple steps, how to store it for maximum freshness, and how to use it in your meals so your whole family can enjoy it.

Raw milk cottage cheese in bowl, topped with fresh strawberries

Why You’ll Love This Recipe

No heating required: Most cottage cheese recipes require heating the milk to help it separate into curds and whey. This raw milk cottage cheese recipe skips the heating step, helping preserve natural probiotics and gut-friendly benefits.
Simple ingredients: Made simply with just raw milk and (optionally) a pinch of salt.
Nourishing & protein-rich: Rich in protein and healthy fats, making it a wholesome, traditional food.
High yield: A small amount of milk goes a long way. For example, 6 cups of milk typically yields about 2 cups of cheese (this may vary slightly depending on the milk).
Versatile: Enjoy it on its own or use it in a variety of recipes.
Mild & creamy: Creamy, mild in flavor, and not overly sour—perfect for beginners.

Ingredients

1500ml / 6 cups full fat raw milk
unrefined salt

Tools You’ll Need

The tools you will need for making this raw milk cottage cheese are:

A large jar, or a large ceramic, glass, or stainless steel mixing bowl
A colander or large strainer
Cheesecloth or a clean piece of white cotton

Stick to ceramic, glass, or metal when choosing your tools. Avoid plastic containers if possible, as sour milk is acidic and may react with plastic, which can lead to unwanted chemicals leaching into your milk.

How To Make It At Home Step By Step

Setting fresh raw milk to sour on counter

Step 1. Pour the milk into a large jar, leaving some space at the top since it will expand as it sours. Seal the jar and place it in a warm spot, out of direct sunlight.

In a cooler kitchen, this process can take longer—my batch took about 48 hours to thicken and separate.

Soured raw milk, ready to be turned into cottage cheese

Step 2. The milk should now be thickened with a yogurt-like consistency, and the whey should have separated from the curds, appearing clear and slightly yellow. The cream will naturally rise to the top.

Your soured milk is now ready to become cottage cheese.

Pouring soured raw milk into colander lined with cheesecloth to drain

Step 3. Line a colander with cheesecloth and set it over a large stockpot or bowl. Slowly pour the soured milk into the cloth, being gentle to avoid breaking the curds. Keeping the curds large will give you more finished cheese.

Allow the milk to drain for several hours, or overnight if your kitchen is cool. The longer it drains, the drier your cottage cheese will be, so adjust to your preference. Because raw milk is a live product, draining times can vary, and the final texture may not always look exactly the same—but it will always be delicious. That’s the beauty of working with live foods.

Bundling the cottage cheese in cheesecloth to speed up draining of whey

Step 4. After the milk has drained for 30–60 minutes, you can gently tip the colander from side to side to help release more whey. Alternatively, gather the cheesecloth and let it rest along the side of the colander to speed up drainage.

Hanging cottage cheese in cheesecloth to drain off whey

Step 5. If your cottage cheese still seems too runny after a few hours, you can tie up the cheesecloth and hang it to drain further. Another option is to tie it to a long-handled wooden spoon and rest it across a pot so the whey can continue to drain.

This step is optional and often not necessary. Since each batch of raw milk behaves a little differently, feel free to adjust the process to suit your milk.

Transferring ready cottage cheese from cheesecloth to bowl

Step 6. Once your raw milk cottage cheese is thick and creamy, transfer it to a large bowl. Stir in about 1/2 teaspoon of unrefined salt using a fork, then taste and adjust as needed.

Salting is optional but enhances flavor and helps extend shelf life. If you plan to use the cottage cheese in sweet dishes, you can skip the salt.

Step 7. You can now place your homemade cottage cheese in the fridge to chill before serving. If you plan to use it in a recipe right away, chilling is not necessary.

Serving Ideas

Raw milk cottage cheese is incredibly versatile—mild, creamy, and just a little tangy—so it works in both savory and slightly sweet ways. Here are some traditional, family-friendly serving ideas that fit beautifully into a real food kitchen:

Spread on sourdough bread with a drizzle of butter and a sprinkle of salt.
Top with fresh herbs (chives, dill, parsley) and olive oil. My grandmother always served cottage cheese in a bowl topped with sliced green onions.
Use as a dip for homemade crackers or tortilla chips.
Drizzle with raw honey and add berries or sliced fruit
Use as a filling for omelets or savory crepes. Make sure to drain your cottage cheese properly, it should be even slightly dry – overly wet cottage cheese doesn’t make a good filling (makes a mess).
Blend into a savory dip with garlic, herbs, and a touch of cream.
Serve slightly chilled but not ice-cold for the best flavor.
To make my cottage cheese taste even better, I mix it with some sour cream (or creme fraiche), fine seal salt and freshly ground black pepper before serving.

Tips For The Best Cottage Cheese

Yield & Milk Amount: The amount of milk specified below will yield approximately 500 grams / 17.6 oz / 2 cups of cottage cheese. You can use a different amount of milk if you like, but for a good yield, use at least 4 cups. The more milk you use, the larger your colander and cheesecloth will need to be.
Use Quality Raw Milk: The quality of your milk directly affects the quality of your finished cheese. For best results, use raw, whole milk. If you’re using very rich milk (such as Jersey milk), you can skim some of the cream off, as long as at least half of the fat remains in the milk.
Choose the Right Container: Instead of a large jar, you can use a large mixing bowl or a stainless steel pot. Be sure to cover the container to keep out flies and debris while the milk is souring.
Alternative to Cheesecloth: If you don’t have cheesecloth, you can use a clean old t-shirt or a piece of white cotton bedsheet. For best results, boil the cloth in plain water for a few minutes to sanitize it before use.
Ideal Souring Temperature: The best and most consistent results come from souring the milk at a warm room temperature (24–28°C / 75–82°F). If it’s too warm (like in the middle of summer), the milk can sour very quickly—sometimes within a few hours—so keep an eye on it. If your kitchen is cold, the milk may take up to 2 days to sour and separate.
Speeding Up in Cold Weather: To help the process along in winter, place the jar near your kitchen stove or on a seedling heat mat (the same kind used to keep tomato and pepper seedlings warm).

Storage Tips

Storing homemade raw milk cottage cheese well is key to keeping it fresh, safe, and tasting its best. Since it’s a fresh, high-moisture cheese, it won’t keep as long as aged cheeses—so cold storage is really important.

Raw milk cottage cheese in clay serving bowl

Short Term Storage:

Store in a glass container with a tight lid (mason jar or food-safe glass container works great) in the coldest part of your fridge.
If liquid separates, you can stir it back in before serving (this is normal and almost always happens).
Always use a clean spoon to remove some of the cheese from the container.
Raw milk cottage cheese is best eaten within 5–7 days.
Adding a little salt can extend the shelf life of your cottage cheese slightly.

Freezing Cottage Cheese:

You can freeze cottage cheese, but it’s not ideal. Freezing changes the texture (it becomes crumbly and watery when thawed).
If you do freeze it, use an airtight container and use within 1–2 months.
Thawed cottage cheese is best used later in cooked dishes (like pancakes or casseroles).

Recipe FAQ

Yes you can, however there may be a change in texture. The same applies to store bought cottage cheese. I usually find that the cottage cheese gets a bit grainy. This does not really matter if you are using it in recipes where it will get mixed in with other ingredients. If you want to eat it on its own, try to avoid freezing it.

You can store it in a covered container in the fridge for up to 5-7 days. If you need to keep it longer than that, you will have to freeze it.

They both have their benefits. Raw milk cottage cheese however still has all the beneficial bacteria from the raw milk and yogurt doesn’t. Milk is usually heated before it’s turned into yogurt. Otherwise the bacteria in the milk might overpower the bacteria in the yogurt starter (which causes the yogurt to be thin). Both cottage cheese and yogurt are good sources of protein and healthy fat.

Paneer is cheese made by boiling the milk and then adding vinegar to get it to separate into curds and whey. Therefore paneer is not a raw milk cheese. There is more than one way of making cottage cheese. The method I show you in this post is to allow the milk to sour and separate naturally and then to strain the curds. This results in a true raw milk cottage cheese with all the probiotic benefits of raw milk intact.

Cream cheese is made from cream and so it is richer in fat soluble vitamins. Cottage cheese is made from soured (also sometimes called clabbered) whole milk. It has less fat but more protein than cream cheese. It is a great option for a healthy protein-rich breakfast or even a post workout snack.

Can you freeze homemade cottage cheese?

How long can you store homemade cottage cheese?

It will last in a covered container in the fridge for up to 5 days if it’s been salted. If you need to keep it longer than that, you will have to freeze it.

Is cottage cheese better for you than yogurt?

Cottage cheese vs paneer: what’s the difference?

Is cottage cheese healthier than cream cheese?

Raw milk cottage cheese in bowl with fresh strawberries and honey on the side — A simple brunch – lettuce and cottage cheese sourdough sandwiches, fresh sliced tomatoes and a cup of tea.

Final Thoughts: A Lost Art Worth Rediscovering

There’s something so grounding about learning the old ways—like turning fresh milk into simple, nourishing cottage cheese. What I love most about traditional recipes is their simplicity: they take very little active time while delivering beautiful flavor and nourishment.

If this kind of slow, traditional living speaks to you, I’d love for you to join my newsletter community. You’ll receive new real food recipes, fermentation tips, and access to my private library of homemaking resources to support your journey.